
*I answered everyone is the comment section.;) Just to confirm something to everyone, I skipped the very first scene of S&S. I wouldn't dream of doing otherwise.*
Well, I haven't finished it yet. I just finished the first episode.
My thoughts? Mixed emotions.
Granted, you can't trust me. The 95' version of S&S will probably always remain my favorite austen adaption. Emma Thompson is just such a good actress, and Kate Winslet just captured Marianne's sweet nature. So, if you are asking me which one I like better, mine without a doubt is the 95' version!! BUT, I'm not saying that the 2008 version isn't good!
Indeed, there are some things that I really appreciated that they added into this film. And I'm sure they will add much more things that I will enjoy. I really enjoyed the scene where Marianne is trying to avoid Colonel Brandon, so funny. But then came Willoughby. At least I think it was Willoughby.
If I remember correctly, Willoughby is tall, and handsome, and came riding on a great white horse. I remember being in awe the first time I watched the 95' version. And can you believe that I laughed when I first saw this scene? Yep, here comes this short, ugly, man waving his hands around like a lunatic! Yes, that's how I saw him. There is no comparison between Greg Wise and Dominic Cooper. I am sorry but there is not. How on earth could Marianne choose Willoughby over Brandon? Oh, yes. That's right. I haven't mentioned Colonel Brandon have I?
Well, I have mixed emotions about him too. Don't get me wrong, he IS sweet! But he IS not Colonel Brandon, in my personal humble opinion.;) Forgive me, but did anyone else get the impression that he seems...kinda...I don't know how to word it, well, "fake"? Perhaps I am just comparing him to Alan Rickman.(who in my opinion is one of the best actors ever).
After hearing me rant & rave about this version, I want you to know that I AM enjoying it! As much as I prefer the 95' version, not for a minute have I regretted watching it. This is just my opinion, so believe me when I say that you probably WILL enjoy and love this version! And probably want to watch it over and over again!!
One of the best things about this version is the Elinore and Edward relationship. They had enough time to develop it more. Though I am dreading the "woodchopping scene".;) Though personally, I am one of those few people who love Hugh Grant's Edward("My heart is, and always will be......your's").
Here's some Period Drama adaptions that I enjoyed;
North and South.(you can't get much better than this)
Sense and Sensibility(1995)
Little Women(1994)
Emma(2009)
Pride and Prejudice(1995)
The Inheritance
Wives and Daughters
Little Dorrit
Cranford
Remember, we have Clearplay. And there are always parts that we may skip, so do your research on any film you plan on watching!;)
~Melinda